When I was growing up, my family and I drove from Colorado Springs to Amarillo, TX every few months. My grandparents, cousins, aunts, and uncles lived there, and I always felt like that was really home. It was a seven hour drive, and we rarely stopped for food – we always packed a cooler full of snacks and sandwiches to eat in the car.
It was your basic car food: oranges, trail mix, turkey sandwiches, crackers, water bottles full of Colorado water (have you ever tasted tap water from Amarillo, TX…do yourself a favor and don’t.)
Anyways, I loved the trips. I loved being with my whole family. And I was always sad to go. Sometimes (okay, every time) I would hide someplace (water heater closet, linen closet, back seat of grandma’s car) and hope my parents went home without me. It never worked.
But there was a saving grace about the trip back home to Colorado.
Nonnie’s brisket sandwiches. A cooler full of them.
This is nothing like my grandma’s brisket sandwich, I didn’t use nearly enough mayonnaise. There weren’t sprouts and spinach on hers. And I’m pretty sure she probably doesn’t even know what a panini press is.
They’re not as good as Nonnie’s either. But it still tasted like a good memory.
Brisket Sandwich
- buffalo brisket, torn into bits
- sprouts
- spinach leaves
- 1 t mayonnaise
- 2 t spicy mustard
- 1 slice mozarella cheese
- 2 slices ciabatta bread
Put all ingredients together and smash in a panini press for 3-4 minutes or until bread is toasted and cheese is melted.


I totally understand what you mean.. I feel that way whenever I recreate a number of things that we used to have when I was growing up, even simple meals like sauteed peppers and eggs sandwiches. Tastes not the same, but like a memory.
You’ve got to be kidding me. I’m making this. Like, really REALLY making this. Soon. Or now.
these sandwiches look delicious! I love trying to recreate a recipe that evokes a memory, even if it never quite tastes the same!
I wish the shops were open so I could make this now!
I’m a Jew. Jew love briskets. Its like part of our religion some how.
And thats probably the only jewish law I follow…
If you’re just going to choose one rule…
These brisket sandwiches look fabulous! I absolutely looooooveee ciabatta bread too!
Love those meals that bring back childhood memories. What does buffalo taste like!?
Like beef but a little leaner…it’s probably my favorite red meat….try it!
I called my great-grandma Nonnie. Just that name alone brings back so many good food memories
Wow. This sandwich looks devine. What a great family story!
Foods that taste like childhood memories are the most special, and so comforting! My extended family lives in Cincinnati, so even though we moved away when I was 6, that’s still “home” to me. My grandma makes this breakfast dish called goetta; it’s really just an old German way to make sausage last by cooking oats and onions in with it. Having goetta and eggs for breakfast reminds me of special breakfast at Grandma’s!
I love memory food like that! The older the recipe, the more tried and true.
YUM!!! that looks amazing, all I need to do is learn how to cook brisket! Will pot roast do? (or are they the same thing–I am so uneducated when it comes to cooking meat!) spinach and sprouts make the sandwich yours and I am sure your Nonnie would approve
I think they are similar, just different cuts of meat. But I’m not sure. I think a roast would work perfectly…just low, slow cooking!
This sounds awesome! A perfect use for a panini press!
Buffalo brisket?!?!? Can you please make me one of these come April??
If we still have buffalo in our fridge, YES! Absolutely! My father-in-law killed this one and then packed our freezer full a few months ago…the best!
sooo my friend and i were asking eacother what is the last thing we would eat before we died (I know we’re sick) but its fun to think about all of the delicious favorite foods I have
anyways, my answer was ANY type of panini…now I love brisket and look forward to the jewish new year (rosh hashana) every year because there is the most amazing brisket with TONS of leftovers…I would haev never thought to make a panini style sandwich with the brisket meat! OMG you are genioussss…I need this sandwich in my life…well first i need a panini maker
Haha, Meeker and I have these types of conversations all of the time…so glad I helped inspire your last meal!
No recipes can ever compete with those you loved as a child, but it’s always fun to try. My mom makes an out-of-this-world brisket. I have yet to even attempt to recreate it.
I went with my husband and some friends this past weekend to Palo Duro Canyon for some camping and hiking. We stayed in Amarillo Friday night and before we headed out on Saturday morning we stopped at Rudy’s for some breakfast tacos. I, as always, got water and when I sat down and had my first sip I about spit it all over my husband. YUCK!! Needless to say, I went back and filled my cup with tea. How does water get that gross?!?!
Palo Duro!! I love it! Who knew something so beautiful could be right outside of Amarillo!? Hope your brought your own water camping! [?]
Aw, I never read this one!!! Good memories. I can’t believe we all go so long without seeing each other since we saw each other so often growing up! Thank goodness Christmas is so soon!