Can’t stop, won’t stop.
I love summertime and I’ll never stop telling you.
Neverrrrrr.
Remember when you went to summer camp and you basically LIVED for that hour after dinner when you could stick your marshmallow on an old bent up hanger and set it ablaze and then wave it around wildly (nearly burning everyone in a three foot radius) trying to figure out the exact MOMENT that it would be perfectly charred and then blow it out?
I always missed that perfect moment and then just proudly proclaimed…I like mine burnt to an unrecognizable crisp, thankyouverymuch.
Yeah, this pie is like that. Except it has tofu, and you don’t need to go to a campfire. But don’t worry…you can’t taste the tofu, and you can totally build a campfire and eat this next to it if you feel like it.
Except in Colorado right now. Don’t even say the word fire. Too soon.
S’more Pie
PRINT Recipe
Graham Cracker Crust
- 1 1/2 C graham cracker crumbs crumbs*
- 1/4 C agave (I like this brand)
- 1/4 C melted butter
Mix the ingredients and press into the bottom of a pie plate. Press another pie plate (or heavy bowl) on top of it and bake at 375 degrees for 8-10 minutes or until crust is lightly browned.
Filling
{only slightly adapted from Alton Brown}
- 13 oz semisweet chocolate chips
- 1/3 cup coffee
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 pound silken tofu, drained
- 1 tablespoon agave
Place enough water in the bottom of a saucepan to come 1 inch up the sides. Bring to a simmer over medium heat.
Melt the chocolate chips with the coffee and vanilla in a medium metal bowl set over the simmering water, stirring often. Combine the tofu, chocolate mixture and agave in a blender or food processor and spin until smooth, about one minute.
Pour the filling into the crust and refrigerate for 2 hours, or until the filling sets firm.Then top the filling with marshmallows and put it under a hot broiler for 2-3 minutes, or until you achieve that perfect char.



Oh holy yum. Yes please. That looks amazing! I always seemed to burn my marshmallows too…or I didn’t cook them enough.
ooooh wow. sign me UP for this!!
you so funny.
i love you a lot too.
I just S’mores Ice Cream this weekend – posting it on 4th of July – and it is killer good and perfect for summer!
I can’t wait to see your ice cream!!
Yummmmmm!
I have a smores pie recipe but it doesn’t have a toasted marshmallow top and that is the best part of smores!
Looks wonderful. I loved (like LOVED) summer camp when I was a kid. My parents sent me to a 3 1/2 week sleep-a-way camp about 2 hours from Austin and I was in heaven! Absolute best memories of my childhood right there!
Oh.my.GOODNESS. This looks amazing! I love s’mores so much, and I have a feeling this pie would be a huge hit with my husband (as long as I didn’t mention that tofu was involved). Thanks for sharing!
Yeah, husbands don’t need to know the secret ingredient.
Ahahahaha – I did the EXACT same thing. Actually for a long while I took to just lighting the whole thing on fire and just letting it go until it burnt out. Great minds think alike
Also? I love you. And now even more for bringing this recipe into my life. Baby A is one lucky little girl to have a mama like you.
Whuuuuut? I have to try it. HAVE TEW.
soooooooooo…i never had a s’more until i moved out here 4 years ago. i KNOW. life starts now!
WHAT??! Man it’s a good thing you moved to Colorado and started your real life. (I mean, s’more eating life)
Hi Katie! I just love your blog. You have such beautiful pictures.
And a beautiful family and cute haircut! I am saving this recipe for sure. Perfect way to get my boyfriend to secretly eat tofu.
Holy crap! That looks so good!!!
OMG! You are a s’mores genius. I am obsessed with s’mores and this is the first time I’ve ever seen a “healthified” version. Amazing.
It’s still got plenty of unhealthy…enough to make it taste good.
Balance
Holy moly that looks amazing. Sooo….that was your dessert…did you have to make a 2nd one for Meeker?
I somehow managed to save a piece for him.
I love that you added tofu! Definitely considering making this JUST SO I can fool the meat-lovers/tofu-haters in my life!
Haha, sneaky, sneaky!
O.M.G – I love this idea!! This is going to happen when we move into the house. With vegan marshmallows, of course.
I used vegan marshmallows, too! They were cheaper at WF.
This looks perfect. I need to eat it. Soon!
I forgot what I was going to say because I just read that Heather has never had a s’more and now I have to figure out how to get this brick out of my pants.
Beautiful & summery!!!!!
I have been missing out on campfire fun living in NYC with no grill and no deck. I think you just became my hero because I can totally do this. You have the perfect amount of char!
I would like s’more pie please!
Love love love – this might be the first time I actually try a tofu dessert recipe!
I love reading your posts! Just spent some time catching up. So many great recipes and fun summer shots! This looks amazing…thanks for sharing, Katie!
You had hangers? Girl, we were scrambling through the woods with sticks that inevitably were too short and so we nearly burned ourselves, along with the marshamallows. Occasionally you’d end up with crispy bits of burnt bark in there, too. Extra fiber?
This looks DIVINE. At first I was sad because I LOVE cream pies but no longer really do dairy. Thank you for the tofu.
holy cow i am drooling over this recipe! it’s gorgeous and delicious! yum!
Love how you used Alton Brown’s recipe as a base. I <3 Alton
[...] here on out it will be summer celebrations and summer celebrations only! I know that will make this girl [...]
This looks freakin’ AMAZING.